ConsenSys Rebuts SEC, Calls MetaMask Allegations Baseless

Ethereum infrastructure powerhouse ConsenSys has formally rebutted the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) allegations of federal securities law violations, heightening its legal stance against the regulator. The SEC previously targeted ConsenSys’ crypto wallet, MetaMask, accusing it of operating as an unregistered broker and securities issuer—claims that ConsenSys categorically denies.

In its recent court filing, ConsenSys criticized both the SEC and its Chair, Gary Gensler, asserting that the agency’s actions amount to an unconstitutional encroachment on the decentralized finance (DeFi) sector. The company’s response reflects growing industry resistance to the SEC’s intensified regulatory approach toward blockchain and cryptocurrency, calling the agency’s legal assertions “unsupported in the law” and emphasizing that these claims “must fail.”

This latest action follows a broader series of legal disputes involving the SEC and ConsenSys. The dispute traces back to ConsenSys founder Joseph Lubin’s earlier suit against the SEC over its investigation into Ethereum’s status, which was closed before the SEC promptly lodged new complaints against MetaMask. The agency now accuses MetaMask of enabling unauthorized securities trading and alleges that its staking services violated existing financial laws. In response, ConsenSys countersued, seeking judicial clarity on the extent of the SEC’s regulatory reach. Legal representative Bill Hughes confirmed that U.S. Judge O’Connor has scheduled an expedited timeline for the proceedings.

The ongoing regulatory tension has had tangible impacts on ConsenSys. CEO Joseph Lubin recently announced a 20% workforce reduction, attributing layoffs to regulatory challenges and broader economic pressures.

Meanwhile, regulatory uncertainty is prompting digital asset firms to look toward the 2024 U.S. general elections as a potential turning point. With over $190 million funneled into pro-crypto super PACs like Fairshake, digital asset companies are actively supporting political outcomes that may shift regulatory oversight. Republican candidate Donald Trump has suggested he would remove Gensler if elected, which could alter the SEC’s regulatory trajectory. Conversely, Gensler’s tenure might extend to 2026 under a potential Democratic administration.

source